Will the broadcast flag interfere with consumers ability to make copies of
DTV content for their personal use, either on personal video recorders or
Yes, it would absolutely interfere, perhaps even making it next to
impossible for most consumers.
Would the digital flag interfere with consumers ability to send DTV content
across networks, such as home digital networks connecting digital set top
boxes, digital recorders, digital servers and digital display devices?
Yes. The digital flag seems expressly designed to limit if not end typical
consumer uses such as these.
Would the broadcast flag requirement limit consumers ability to use their
existing electronic equipment (equipment not built to look for the flag) or
make it difficult to use older components with new equipment that is
compliant with the broadcast flag standard?
Yes, the broadcast flag would make it impossible to use existing equipment.
The current difficulties with older computer and audio components shows
exactly the types of problems to be encountered in this area as well.
Would a broadcast flag requirement limit the development of future
equipment providing consumers with new options?
Most definitely. Any time innovation and competition are stiffled, new
options for the consumer (as well as better choices and lower prices) are
always the victims.
What will be the cost impact, if any, that a broadcast flag requirement
would have on consumer electronics equipment?
The cost will undoubtedly rise dramatically. Consumers would be forced to
purchase new, more expensive equipment -- if that even becomes available.
Proponents do not want consumers to have the freedoms and abilities
available without the broadcast flag and seem to be looking for a way to
monopolize emerging technology. Such a position is blatantly unfair to
consumers. The FCC needs to protect U.S. consumers, not the entertainment
industry, which is perfectly capable of protecting itself.